Laws on recording working time, country by country

Do employers have to record working time? In the EU the answer changed in 2019. This article walks through the Working Time Directive, the Court of Justice judgment that followed, and what Germany, Spain, Denmark, France, the UK and the US say, with a link to the official text for every statement.

9 min read

The EU baseline: the Working Time Directive

Directive 2003/88/EC sets the minimum rules on working time across the EU. In plain terms, it says:

  • Daily rest (Article 3): at least 11 consecutive hours in each 24-hour period.
  • Weekly rest (Article 5): an uninterrupted 24 hours in each seven-day period, on top of the daily rest.
  • Maximum weekly working time (Article 6): an average of no more than 48 hours in each seven days, including overtime. Member states may calculate the average over a reference period of up to four months (Article 16).

The Directive does not say, in so many words, that the employer must keep a record of hours. That gap is what the Court of Justice filled.

The CJEU judgment of 14 May 2019 (C-55/18)

In the case CCOO v Deutsche Bank (C-55/18), a Spanish trade union asked whether Deutsche Bank had to record the hours its staff worked. The Grand Chamber of the Court of Justice of the European Union ruled on 14 May 2019 that Articles 3, 5 and 6 of the Directive, read with the Charter of Fundamental Rights, preclude national law that does not require employers to set up a system enabling the duration of time worked each day by each worker to be measured.

In practice, a limit on hours cannot be checked without a record of hours. The German court below relied on it. The Court left the details to member states, so the rules below differ.

Germany: Arbeitszeiterfassung

On 13 September 2022 the Federal Labour Court (Bundesarbeitsgericht) decided case 1 ABR 22/21. A works council had asked to force the introduction of an electronic system for recording working time. The court rejected the works council's claim, because the duty to record already follows from law and so leaves no initiative right.

The reasoning matters more than the outcome. The court read section 3(2) no. 1 of the Occupational Safety Act (Arbeitsschutzgesetz) in line with the Directive and the CJEU judgment. Employers must record the start and end of daily working time, using an objective, reliable and accessible system. The court also noted that EU law does not demand an electronic system in every case, and that the works council keeps a co-determination right over how recording is designed.

A law firm summary of the press release adds that the court did not prescribe technical or electronic recording (Advant Beiten). If you search for Arbeitszeiterfassung, also check whether lawmakers have added to this since the decision, because the decision is a court ruling, not a new statute.

Spain: registro de jornada

Spain wrote the rule into statute before the CJEU ruled. Real Decreto-ley 8/2019 of 8 March 2019 (published in the BOE on 12 March 2019) added a section 9 to article 34 of the Workers' Statute (Estatuto de los Trabajadores). It requires the company to guarantee a daily record of working time (registro de jornada) that shows the exact start and end time of each worker's day.

  • How the record is organised is set by collective bargaining or a company agreement or, failing that, by the employer after consulting worker representatives.
  • The company keeps the records for four years ("durante cuatro años").
  • The records stay available to the workers, their legal representatives and the labour inspectorate (Inspección de Trabajo y Seguridad Social).

Denmark: the 2024 registration duty

Denmark added the duty by amending its act implementing parts of the Working Time Directive. The registration duty took effect on 1 July 2024, according to Dansk Erhverv. The consolidated text is LBK no. 982 of 12 August 2024. Section 4 b says:

  • The employer must introduce an objective, reliable and accessible system for registering working time, which makes it possible to measure each employee's daily working time.
  • The employer must make sure the employee can see their own information in the system.
  • The employer keeps the registered information for 5 years after the end of the period used to calculate the employee's average weekly working time.
  • For employees who have agreed to work more than 48 hours a week on average, extra record-keeping and reporting to the Working Environment Authority (Arbejdstilsynet) applies.

The act has exceptions for some groups, so check section 2 and the guidance for your own case.

France: décompte de la durée du travail

French labour law has long required employers to count working time. For employees who do not follow the same posted collective schedule, article D3171-8 of the Code du travail sets a daily method and a weekly one: record each day the start and end of each work period (by any means) or the number of hours worked, and total each employee's hours for the week. Other rules apply to staff who work to a posted collective schedule.

United Kingdom: Working Time Regulations

Under regulation 9 of the Working Time Regulations 1998, an employer must keep records adequate to show that it has complied with the limits on working time, night work and rest, and keep them for two years from the date they were made. The employer can keep them in whatever form it reasonably thinks fit, and does not have to record each worker's daily hours if it can show compliance in another way.

The headline limit is in regulation 4: an average of 48 hours a week over a 17-week reference period, unless the worker has agreed in writing to work more. Note the difference from the EU position: the UK rule is about records adequate to show compliance, not a system that measures every worker's daily time.

United States: FLSA record-keeping

The Fair Labour Standards Act (FLSA) requires employers to keep records of hours. According to the Department of Labour's fact sheet on FLSA recordkeeping, employers must record the hours each non-exempt worker works each day, the total hours each workweek, and when the workweek begins. Payroll records are kept for at least three years, and records used to compute wages, such as time cards and work schedules, for two years. Employers need not use a time clock or a specific format, as long as the record is complete and accurate.

State laws can add to this. This article does not cover them.

The rules side by side

CountryWhat must be recordedHow longSource
EU (CJEU, 2019)A system to measure each worker's daily timeLeft to member statesC-55/18
GermanyStart and end of daily working time, in an objective, reliable, accessible systemNot set by the decisionBAG 1 ABR 22/21
SpainDaily record with exact start and end time4 yearsRDL 8/2019
DenmarkDaily working time in an objective, reliable, accessible system5 years after the averaging periodLBK 982/2024
FranceDaily start and end of work periods, or hours worked, and a weekly total (staff off the collective schedule)See the Code du travailD3171-8
United KingdomRecords adequate to show compliance2 yearsRegulation 9
United StatesDaily and weekly hours of non-exempt workers2 or 3 years, by record typeDOL fact sheet 21

What a timesheet with Standard hours can help with

No timesheet makes a firm compliant by itself, and this article does not say that Matrix satisfies any particular law. What a good timesheet does is give you a clean record to show when someone asks. In Matrix, that is the free Timesheet, with Standard hours added when you want the time compared with a schedule.

In the free Timesheet

  • Each employee registers time with a timer, a week sheet, from and to times, or just the total.
  • Approved time is locked, and an admin can reopen it only with a reason, logged with who and when.
  • A history on every entry shows who changed what and when, also on deleted entries.
  • A payroll period sent to payroll is locked for good, and can be downloaded again.
  • Time exports as CSV, Excel or PDF, so a record can be handed over.

With Standard hours

  • Each employee gets a weekly schedule, with hours for each weekday, or a rotation over 2 to 8 weeks.
  • For each employee and day, Matrix compares the registered time with the schedule and shows the difference, over or under. Time off such as vacation and sickness counts as registered time.
  • Public holidays have 0 Standard hours, and time registered on one is a difference you can tag.
  • Differences are explained in lines, each with a tag of your own, such as Overtime 50%.
  • Matrix calculates nothing about compensation. The tags and the tagged differences go to your payroll system in the payroll file, or through Zapier.

Standard hours is EUR 1 per employee, per month, with a 7-day free trial. The Timesheet underneath it is free.

Questions and answers

Keep a clean record of working time

Start with the free Timesheet. Add Standard hours when you want every day compared with the schedule.

Open the live demo

Free. No card needed.